scala self type vs extends


When our C class is instantiated, B.toString is invoked, which then invokes A.hi.

There is a moment in our life when we read about Self Types for the first time and we think I dont know what to do with this, is this some kind of fancy inheritance?. A class defined without a dependency on, or even knowledge of, a given trait can take advantage of that traits functionality. - Software Engineering Stack Exchange, Real-World Scala: Dependency Injection (DI). If you worked through the exercises in Chapter7 (see Exercises) youll know what tool Im talking about. For this tutorial Im going with the second approach, which may not be recommended but avoids the use of the SBT .sbt file format language in favor of the regular Scala syntax used in the second approach. However, if you want a class with a definitive set of fields, and these automatically generated methods are useful, then a case class may be right for you. Is there a more appropriate data type that it should take, one that supports variable numbers of columns but knows how to print out strings versus double values? Remember to keep writing tests as you work through the rest of the exercises in this book, using them to assert how your solutions should work and to catch any (unforseeable!) When you have compiled your code, execute it by running the scala command with the name of the object. Make sure your report generation code takes the maximum line width as an argument. Now write the modified text back to the file it was read from. The standard identifier used in self types is self, although any other identifier may be used. A self type is a trait annotation that asserts that the trait must be mixed in with a specific type, or its subtype, when it is added to a class. What are the most appropriate monadic collections to use in this function? Command-line applications written in Scala may not replace native tools and shell scripts, because their slower startup time (a known problem in the JVM) and greater memory requirements may make them less desirable for all environments. Unlike objects, however, traits can take type parameters, which can help to make them extremely reusable.

An alternate method for using traits is to add them to a class when the class is instantiated. Well also see how traits can be used not only in class definitions but in class instantiations as well, providing built-in dependency injection. A trait with a self type cannot be added to a class that does not extend the specified type. The Test Results view in IntelliJ IDEA. The series about Scala types system continues. Software Engineering Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for professionals, academics, and students working within the systems development life cycle. If you are more familiar with text-editing environments like Sublime Text, Vim, or Emacs, you should spend some time becoming familiar with working in an IDE. Lets conclude this exercise with an actual exercise for you to implement: add additional tests to our HtmlUtilsSpec test class. This will pick up the Build base class, the property names (aka settings) like name and version, and the special SBT operators like :=, %, and %%. Print these out to verify you have captured them correctly.

By using a dependency management and build tool, we can compile and execute against these dependencies while letting the tool handle library downloading and path configuration. Sometimes we need to use Self Types because there is no way to accomplish our objective with Inheritance, but in some occasions it will depends on the semantics that we want to give to our objects or how much control we want to give over their construction. A class referring to an undefined object, being compiled without the object, would have led to a compilation error. To be even more precise, case classes arent only classes. rev2022.7.21.42639. This process of taking a horizontal list of a class and traits being extended, and reforming them into a vertical chain of one class extending another, is known as linearization. By supporting multiple inheritance by classes, traits extend the possibilities of highly reusable code. The real value in instantiating with traits is in adding new functionality or configurations to existing classes. Lets try an example that demonstrates the benefit of self types. In the exercises for previous chapters you may have been writing .scala files executed directly by the scala command. The fromFile method in the Scala librarys io.Source object (we can call it by its correct name now) is used to read each file, and the collection method mkString is used to convert the lines back into a single String for printing.

Although we clearly dont need one to compile and run an application, we will need it when we start adding external dependencies, i.e., external Java and Scala libraries. SPAM free - no 3rd party ads, only the information about waitingforcode! Properties, XmlProperties, JSonProperties, XmlStreamProperties, XmlMapProperties, JsonStreamProperties and JsonMapProperties. Do weekend days count as part of a vacation? Thus, Alphanumerical instance is also an instance of Letter and Number. This separation helps to clarify the difference between global and instance-based fields and methods and provides a safer and more understandable design. That's the most important difference. Now well run it. What are the most appropriate monadic collections to use in this function? This (as far as I know) cannot be done with self annotations. * Base code with extension * Base code with self types * Feature added to the extension style * Feature added to the self type style, OK, think I can try that before the bounty runs out ;). Why does hashing a password result in different hashes, each time? However, it's not an overridden method ! TAGS: Both types of SBT build scripts use some nonstandard Scala operators such as assignments (:=) and dependency grouping (%). There are several public Maven repository search engines for finding libraries that include support for formatting the library as a dependency in SBT. In the first case, the precise type of B is crystallised at the point A extends it. The purpose of this article is to talk about Inheritance and Self Types, their similarities and differences. Could you provide some code examples that show that one method is more extensible and flexible than the other? I have a feeling that you are going to be arguing that they are equivalent, although I'd be happy to be proved wrong if you said more about your criteria. It means that all implementations of a trait with self-type will need to provide the behavior for this self-type. This exercise will consist of adding a test to the IDE, executing it, and verifying its successful outcome.

Our trait needs to invoke TestSuite.start() but cannot extend TestSuite because it would require hardcoding the input parameter.

OReilly members experience live online training, plus books, videos, and digital content from nearly 200 publishers. When designing a model it is often more logical to use inheritance because of the semantics that comes with inheriting from another object. If youre already familiar with executing tests in an IDE this should be a fairly simple exercise. Another difference is where A and B provides methods of the same name. In order to solve this problem we can use structural typing, it is not necessary to be an Animal to be Security, it is enough to understand the method stop. Now add a new HtmlUtilsSpec class under src/test/scala, creating the directory if necessary. Create a new Scala trait titled SafeStringUtils and add the following source: Verify that the trait compiles in the IDE. The Future object uses apply() to take your function parameter and invoke it in a background thread. It understands stop, bark and lookout because is a Dog with Security. In this example well create a case class and see how many of its automatically generated methods we can hit: Heres our companion objects factory method, Character.apply(). privacy policy 2014 - 2022 waitingforcode.com. Well look at more uses of objects in the next several sections.

When you parse the JSON response, Json4s will insert only the fields you have defined in your case class and ignore the rest. Extracts the instance into a tuple of its fields, making it possible to use case class instances for pattern matching. In the test body, the equal operator ensures that the value preceding should is equal to its argument, here the empty string "". You can still use the var keyword if you need a variable field.

I/O functions are those that work with external data, such as with files, databases, and external services.

Right-click in the Hello.scala source view and select Run Hello. A class that takes a type parameter is a type, but every time it is instantiated with a type parameter, that too is a type. Lets work on a different example from this chapter. Heres an example of a solid base class plus traits that add extra functionality when combined with a subclass. To be more precise, case classes should be included with classes as the core building block of Scala applications. In the other side, we've FrontendSoftwareEngineer trait working exclusively with JavaScript. When a trait is "sealed" all of its subclasses are declared within the same file and that makes the set of subclasses finite which allows certain compiler checks. Are there there any feature areas that arent yet tested? Would it be useful to provide an object version of this trait? How should we do boxplots with small samples? If trait A extends B, then mixing in A gives you precisely B plus whatever A adds or extends. Included are steps to create the file, compile it, and execute it as an application, all inside a shell. Last but not least, who uses our traits can decide the order in which they are used, so thanks to Trait Linearization the final result can be different although the traits used are the same. It takes one or more filenames (or paths) and prints each one to the console: This time were making use of the input arguments. SBT supports writing a build script in its own Scala-like script language, stored in the file build.sbt at the root level of the project. What is the functional difference between A winning vs A overriding? The scala command will execute the contents of your file as if they were entered in a REPL, but you dont end up with compiled classes. You should design a case class that contains the exact fields you want to parse from the JSON, using the Option type for nullable or optional fields. A trait is a kind of class that enables multiple inheritance. For instance, if a structural type defines a method called a(), the class implementing it will also need to have an a() method implemented. There is one important thing here, although Security doesnt have a method stop, neither it extends from Animal, it can call stop method. The companion objects unapply method allows us to decompose the instance into its parts, binding the first field (see Matching with Wildcard Patterns) and using a literal value to match the second field. Many developers choose the latter, using them in place of regular classes when they can. Like the operations in Scalas collections they are only good for a single task, but when chained together they create a bounty of new opportunities and possibilities. You have set the relationship in stone. Importing instance members is a great way to streamline your code. Traits look about the same as any other type of class. At the most basic level they read input arguments, perhaps read from the input stream, and then write to the output stream. Note that the JSON document returned by the API is an array, so you will probably need to invoke the extract method with a List (e.g., extract[List[GithubIssue]]): DefaultFormats has support for common date formats as well as numbers and strings. An object gets automatically instantiated the first time it is accessed in a running JVM, which also means that until it is accessed the first time it wont get instantiated. Importing fields and methods does not override privacy controls, so only those that would be normally accessible can be imported.

Lets make it more interesting by adding a second trait. Well extend both the parent class and one of the traits that extends the parent class. Objects are less flexible than traits, but provide a built-in singleton mechanism with far less boilerplate than Javas singleton tricks or its static members and classes. More complex applications may work with persistent data such as files and databases, access other computers over a network, or launch new applications.

Without a specific build script it will look for mainstream Scala code under src/main/scala and test-only Scala code under src/test/scala. Are there any appropriate monadic collections to use in this function? Besides the special companion access to private fields, we could not have entered them in the REPL without paste mode because the class and object refer to each other. In practice, it would mean we can assign to him as well as Scala tasks as JavaScript ones. If you havent installed this tool yet, see Isnt SBT Hard to Learn? Why would weneed a cyclic dependency between types? A popular use of self types is to add functionality with traits to classes that require input parameters.

The current approach of editing in the REPL and/or executing .scala files directly wont work for the applications youll need to build. It only takes a minute to sign up. The suffixes of Wizard and esq were hardcoded in traits, but added to separate user instances at instantiation time.

However, we gained flexibility and simplicity with these instantiation traits, and avoided writing unnecessary code. SBT favors convention over configuration. You should be able to write a test that gives the string this is is not a test and receives an instance that will reveal the word is as the top used word.

Here, in the above example, auto is an abstract type and self-type of auto with the car. To better understand the ScalaTest framework, I recommend that you take a break from this exercise and browse the official documentation at the ScalaTest website.

However, it can declare itself to be a subtype of that parent class with a self type and then add its functionality.

A self type is added immediately following the opening brace of the trait definition, and includes an identifier, the requested type, and an arrow (=>). To create a command-line application in Scala, add a main method that takes an array of strings as input arguments. They do make writing command-line tools more fun, however, and are a great way to learn the language.

An object is a type of class that can have no more than one instance, known in object-oriented design as a singleton. have XmlProperties and JSonProperties use self types (since they require the apply method) an have StreamProperties and MapProperties use inheritance (since they supply it)?